Home BBQ Tips and Tricks Barbecue and grilling are not the same fire

Barbecue and grilling are not the same fire

943
0

Barbecue and grilling are not the same fire

I say grill when I mean the hot grate and dinner in under an hour. I say barbecue when the meat is sitting in smoke, somewhere around 250°F, long enough that I have done the dishes and thought about a nap. Using one word for both is how a gas burner and a pork shoulder end up in the same sentence, and then everybody is mad.

The spelling, barbeque or barbecue, is not this argument. That one is short and lives at barbeque versus barbecue. This one is about heat.

Grilling

Direct heat, lid up or lid down for a few minutes, food that is already tender. Steaks, chops, skewers, vegetables, thin fish, burgers. The skill is a hot grate, salt at the right time, and getting the food off before you “just give it another minute” three times. The setup is direct or indirect. The weeknight I cook most often in this style is pork souvlaki. A chop is grilled pork chops. A steak is a steak.

Barbecue

Low heat, wood smoke, and a cut that needs time because it has collagen to melt. Brisket, shoulder, ribs, sometimes a turkey. The method with the patience named in the title is low and slow. The brisket, which is the one that taught me the difference in my hands and not just in a definition, is how I smoke a brisket. If the outside is done and the inside is not, you were grilling a cut that wanted barbecue. If the meat is dry and gray and it took twelve hours, you were barbecuing a cut that wanted a hot grate, or the pit ran too hot. Both have happened to me. The second one was a rack of lamb I tried to “make special” with a full afternoon of smoke. It wanted eight minutes.

The grill is the tool. It is not the method.

A kettle can grill and it can barbecue. Coals in the middle, you are grilling. Coals to one side, lid on, a chunk of oak, you are barbecuing, or at least you are trying. Gas can grill easily and can approximate barbecue with a smoke tube and the patience to stay at the knobs. It will not be an offset. I am fine with that. The honest comparison of the two fuels is charcoal or gas.

Regions argue about sauce and animal and wood. They are mostly arguing inside barbecue, not about whether a Tuesday kebab counts. Those plates are the regional styles. The history of how the slow version got its name is where the word came from.

When somebody at the table says they barbecued burgers, I let it go. Then I cook the burgers hot and fast, because the meat does not care what we called it. It cares where the coals were.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here
Captcha verification failed!
CAPTCHA user score failed. Please contact us!