Charcoal or gas
I own a kettle and I have cooked on other people’s gas grills enough to stop treating it as a moral question. Charcoal tastes like a fire. Gas lights, holds, and lets me talk to someone. The food decides which one I light. A Tuesday souvlaki is happy on either if the grate is hot. A Saturday brisket wants coal and wood. Pretending they are the same machine with different fuel caps is how people end up disappointed in a $20 steak and blaming the rub.
What changes
Charcoal runs hotter at the grate when you want a sear, and it is easier to set up as a two-zone fire: coals on one side, meat on the other. That setup is direct and indirect. It also asks you to light a chimney, wait, and manage vents. Those vents are temperature control. Lump versus the pillow-shaped briquettes is a separate choice, here.
Gas is a knob. It will sear if you preheat with the lid down and the burners are not timid. It will not make wood smoke unless you add a box or a packet, and that smoke is a hint, not an offset. Low and slow on gas is possible and it is written as a section of low and slow, including the part where I do not pretend it is a pit.
Electric, briefly
An electric grill or an electric smoker is a different appliance. I use the smoker version when I want a set number and I am willing to give up the fire. That page is the electric smoker. It does not belong in a fight between charcoal and gas except to say it exists and it tastes like the third thing.
Safety is not a tiebreaker for flavor. Both fuels can burn a house down in their own style. The habits are BBQ safety. Buy the one you will light on a Wednesday. A charcoal grill that stays in the garage is a less useful machine than a gas grill that cooks dinner.





































