Home BBQ Recipes Grilling a steak

Grilling a steak

714
0

Grilling a steak

I have ruined more steaks by fussing than by neglect. The ones that work are thick, dry on the surface, salted ahead, and left alone on a grate that is hotter than feels polite. Grill marks are a photograph. A brown crust across the face is dinner.

The cut

Ribeye if I want fat to do the work. Strip if I want a cleaner slice. A filet is tender and easy to make boring, so I do not buy it unless someone asked. Thickness matters more than the romance of the name: under an inch, and the middle is done before the outside has color. I aim for an inch and a half. The map of the animal, if you are staring at the case, is meat cuts. This page is only the cook.

Salt at least forty minutes ahead, or right as it hits the grate. The in-between window, ten minutes, pulls water out and leaves it on the surface, which is how you steam a steak over coals. Pepper after the sear if the fire is ripping, because pepper burns and turns bitter. I learned that by being generous at the wrong time.

Heat

Direct, full chimney, grate too hot to hover over. The difference between that and a bake is direct versus indirect. Pat the meat dry. A thin film of oil on the steak, not a puddle on the bars. Down. One minute without touching. If it sticks, it is not ready to turn. The crust lesson, including reverse sear for the really thick ones, is how I get a crust.

I pull with a thermometer in from the side. Rare around 120°F, medium-rare 130°F, medium 140°F, and then it climbs a few degrees while it rests. I rest it five minutes on a warm plate, not in a covered pan, or the crust softens. Somebody at the table always wants it past medium. I cook that one a minute longer instead of arguing. Sauces do not go on a steak in my house. If you want a glaze, cook pork chops. If you want all afternoon, that is brisket, which is a different muscle and a different fire.

The thick one

Over an inch and a half, I start it on the cool side until it is about 15°F under the target, then sear a minute a side. Starting on the coals and trying to finish gently has left me with a gray band more times than I will admit. Fuel, if you are choosing a grill for this, is charcoal or gas. Charcoal is easier to get this hot. Gas will do it if the burners are not timid and the grate has had time to heat.