Home BBQ Recipes The BBQ sauces I actually keep

The BBQ sauces I actually keep

701
0

The BBQ sauces I actually keep

I used to own one sauce and put it on everything, including brisket that did not want it. The bottle was sweet, thick, and loud, and it covered a lot of mediocre meat. Once the meat got better I started tasting the sauce, which was inconvenient. Now I keep a few, and I pick by the animal and by whether the sugar is going to see direct fire.

This page is the map. The recipes live on their own URLs so they do not fight each other for the same search. If you only bookmark one, bookmark the one you will cook this weekend.

Three families, then the odd ones

The sweet sauce is ketchup, brown sugar, and smoke. It belongs on chicken, on a pork chop in the last five minutes, and on ribs at the end. It does not belong on a steak, and it does not go on at the start of a hot sear or you will eat carbon.

The tangy sauce leans on vinegar and a little mustard. I use it when the meat is rich, especially pork shoulder after it is pulled, because sweetness alone makes a fatty pile cloying. Carolina cooks have been right about this longer than I have been alive. The regional picture is on regional BBQ styles.

The spicy sauce is the sweet one with a pepper that means it. I do not call a sauce spicy because it has a pinch of black pepper. If you want heat that still tastes like fruit, the blueberry jalapeƱo and the blueberry habanero are different peppers and they should stay different jars.

Kansas City is its own jar

Kansas City sauce is sweet and thick and tomato-heavy, and it is the one I paint on burnt ends. It is related to the sweet sauce and it is not the same pot. If I merge them, both pages get worse and the burnt ends taste vague. The cook those ends belong to is burnt ends.

Jars I make when I am bored of ketchup

Prickly pear is for the week the fruit shows up and I am tired of brown sugar. Beer and bacon is a pork sauce, obviously, and it is too heavy for fish. Black pepper sauce and black garlic are the two I make when I want savory instead of candy. Blueberry bourbon is a glaze for chicken or a spoon on a pork chop, not a mop for a brisket.

When a bottle of Blues Hog runs out mid-cook, I make the copycat. It is not their recipe. It is the one I can stir together from the pantry so the ribs still get painted. Same story for Big John’s and for Bonne Chere. I would rather say “copycat” than pretend I have a factory formula.

What is not a sauce

A rub is dry. It goes on early. The base mix is the rub I use, and the beef version is just salt and pepper on the Texas rub page. A marinade has enough liquid to sit in, and it has a time limit. That is how I marinate. If a page on this site ever tells you one bottle is the ultimate sauce for every meat, it is an old page and it should be gone.

I also do not chase a sauce just because the label says it has no high-fructose corn syrup. I read the sugar line, I taste it on a hot rib, and I decide. The ingredient is a preference. It is not a personality.