Home BBQ Recipes How I smoke a brisket

How I smoke a brisket

817
0

How I smoke a brisket

I pulled my first brisket because the clock said it was time and I was hungry. It looked dark. It sliced like a pot roast that had missed the party. The one that finally behaved was a 12-pound prime I cooked for a cousin’s name day, on the offset, with post oak, and I left it alone until a skewer went through the flat the way it goes through warm peanut butter. The meat thermometer read 203°F in the thickest part of the flat. A thinner corner was already past that. I trusted the feel, not the average.

The cut I buy

I want a whole packer, flat and point still attached, with a fat cap I can leave about a quarter inch thick. The flat is the lean slice you put on a tray. The point is fattier, and if the cook goes right it becomes burnt ends. I skip the already-trimmed “brisket flat” unless I am feeding four people and I say so on the board, because it will finish drier and it will not give me that second plate.

Choice grade works. Prime is more forgiving if the fire wanders. I have cooked select. I do not recommend it unless you like chewing. If you are staring at the case and the names blur, the meat cuts page is the map. This page is the cook.

Trim, salt, and then go away

Hard fat in the seam between point and flat comes off, or the smoke never reaches the meat under it. Soft fat on the cap stays, thinned so it will render instead of sitting there like a candle. I salt it the night before, about half a teaspoon of kosher salt per pound, and leave it uncovered in the fridge. Pepper goes on in the morning, coarse, heavier than looks polite. No sugar. Sugar burns in a long cook and I want bark, not candy.

That salt-and-pepper coat is the whole of my Texas rub. If I want sauce, it is on the side, and it is not this meat’s job to carry it.

Fire

Offset, 250°F at the grate, measured where the meat sits and not on the dome thermometer that came with the pit. Dome thermometers lie. I learned that the expensive way, which is written up under holding a pit temperature. Wood is post oak. Hickory will do if oak is not in the shed. I do not run mesquite for twelve hours. It turns bitter on me past the second split. Which tree for which meat is the whole argument of smoking wood.

Fat cap toward the fire on an offset, because that side takes the heat. On a kettle I bank the coals to one side and put the brisket on the empty side, which is just indirect heat with a pan of water under the meat if the day is dry. Spritzing every twenty minutes cools the pit and gives me something to fuss with. I spritz once, with a little cider vinegar and water, when the surface looks dull. Then I stop opening the lid.

The stall, the wrap, and the part I used to rush

Somewhere around 160°F the temperature sits there while the meat sweats. That is not a broken pit. If I am tired of feeding the fire I wrap in butcher paper, not foil. Foil braises it. Paper lets a little smoke keep moving and still pushes through the stall. I have also gone unwrapped when the bark was already the way I wanted and I had the afternoon. Both have fed people. The unwrapped one had better bark. The wrapped one was juicier when I had rushed the early hours.

It is done when the probe slides in with almost no push, usually between 200°F and 205°F in the flat. A brisket is safe to eat long before that. Those last degrees are about collagen, not about safety. The safety rules, the resting, and what I will not leave on a side table in the sun are on BBQ food safety. The full time chart, if you want a number before you commit your Saturday, is smoking times and temperatures. A twelve-pound packer at 250°F has taken me anywhere from ten to fourteen hours plus a rest. I do not promise your pit my clock.

Rest it or waste the day

I hold it in a dry cooler, still wrapped, for at least an hour. Two is better. Slicing into a screaming-hot brisket sends the juice onto the board and leaves you with gray meat and a puddle. Slice the flat against the grain, pencil thick. Turn the point when the grain changes direction. If the point is too rich for the tray, cube it, sauce it, and send it back to the pit. That is the burnt-end path, and it is a better use of the fatty end than pretending it slices like the flat.

The slow cooker, since people ask

I have cooked a small flat in a slow cooker with onion and a cup of the Kansas City sauce when I did not have a day. It made shredded beef for buns. It did not make brisket. If that is the meal you want, say so and season it like a pot roast. Do not call it the same thing I waited on all Saturday.